Wage Counsel Group
← All posts

“Headless” PAGA Goes Before the California Supreme Court This Week: What Employers Need to Know

Published November 2, 2026

On Tuesday, November 3, 2026, the California Supreme Court will hear oral argument in Leeper v. Shipt, Inc. The case is listed second on the court’s 9:00 a.m. calendar in San Francisco. The question is narrow but the stakes are not: can a worker sue under the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) on behalf of other employees only, leaving out their own individual claim, and so keep the case out of arbitration? proskauer

Background

Two earlier decisions set the stage. In Viking River Cruises v. Moriana (2022), the U.S. Supreme Court held that an individual PAGA claim can be compelled to arbitration under a valid arbitration agreement. In Adolph v. Uber (2023), the California Supreme Court held that a plaintiff whose individual PAGA claim goes to arbitration does not lose standing to pursue the non-individual claims in court.

Plaintiffs’ lawyers then tried a workaround. If the complaint pleads only non-individual PAGA claims, there is no individual claim to arbitrate. These are the “headless” actions. calchamber

The split in the Courts of Appeal

The lower courts disagree.

  • Leeper (Second District, December 2024). The court held that every PAGA action necessarily includes an individual PAGA claim, so the individual portion must be sent to arbitration and the rest stayed. The plaintiff alleged that Shipt misclassified her and other workers as independent contractors. calchambercalchamber
  • Rodriguez v. Packers Sanitation (Fourth District). This court took a different view. The Supreme Court has deferred further action in Rodriguez pending its ruling in Leeper. calchamberlexblog
  • Castillo v. Belkorp AG (Fifth District, October 23, 2026). This is the newest decision. The court approved a headless action under the post-July 2024 version of the statute and held there was nothing to arbitrate. It applies the amended statute, not the pre-reform version, which matters because most current notices fall under the amendments. cdflaborlaw

The Supreme Court took review of Leeper on its own motion in April 2025. Argument preview coverage indicates the justices are expected to examine the meaning of the word “and” in the statute, specifically whether the statutory language permits a representative-only action. calchamberlaw360

What a ruling could mean

  • If the court sides with Shipt: arbitration agreements keep real leverage over PAGA. Every PAGA action would carry an individual claim, and employers with enforceable agreements could compel that portion to arbitration.
  • If the court sides with Leeper: plaintiffs can plead around arbitration agreements by omitting the individual claim, which weakens the practical value of those agreements in PAGA cases.

The court has 90 days from submission to decide, so expect an opinion by roughly early February 2027. Until then, the Courts of Appeal remain split, and which rule applies may depend on the district where a case is filed.

What employers should do now

Don’t wait for the opinion to act.

  1. Review your arbitration agreements. Confirm they are enforceable, current, and clearly cover individual PAGA claims. A court cannot compel arbitration under an agreement that is defective or superseded.
  2. Prepare for either outcome. Even if headless actions survive, the non-individual claims still go forward in court. Arbitration was never a complete defense to PAGA exposure.
  3. Build the “reasonable steps” record. Under the 2024 reforms, penalties are capped at 15% of the default amount when an employer took all reasonable steps to comply before receiving the notice, and 30% if it did so afterward. Courts have looked for dated training rosters, written audit reports, signed handbook acknowledgments, and corrective-action files. A documented payroll audit is the strongest evidence you can have. skylinebusinesslaw
  4. Watch the regulations. The Labor and Workforce Development Agency has separately proposed first-ever PAGA regulations. If finalized, they would apply to matters pending at or filed after the effective date. We will cover those in a separate post. fisherphillips

We will publish a follow-up when the Supreme Court issues its decision.


This post is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship with Wage Counsel Group or ELE Consulting Inc. Employment laws change frequently, and their application depends on the specific facts of each situation. Information is current as of November 2, 2026.